Author Archives: Law

On 5th Edition Advancement

Aaaaaaand themes are gone. When 5th Edition was first a thing (in a playtest I didn’t play that may never have actually happened thanks to an NDA), there are a few things that were awkward but that really excited me. … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary | Tagged | 1 Comment

Obsidian Portal Reforged

Just a general name drop: the Obsidian Portal Kickstarter is ending soon. It’s a tool I’ve used before so the prospect of improvements excites me a bit, and there’s the opportunity to get a discount on premium membership in case … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Comments Off on Obsidian Portal Reforged

Alternate Hit Point Systems (or, Various Ways to Make Crits Stop Being Fun)

There’s a quiet assumption in 3rd Edition and its related systems that hit potions don’t actually keep track of damage. Getting cut by a sword is normally quite severe if not fatal, and gunshots and firealls aren’t any better. Rather, … Continue reading

Posted in DMing, House Rules | Tagged , , | 5 Comments

On the Premium Spell Compendium

I know it’s not really in keeping with the theme of the blog, but I have to point out how ridiculous that Wizards is putting previews of the Spell Compendium reprint on its website. When I visit the Wizards website, … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary | Tagged | Comments Off on On the Premium Spell Compendium

On the Speed of Experience

The more I read about 5th Edition, the less I like it. Luckily, the players who comment on official Wizards articles feel the opposite way, so at least we balance out. This time the issue is with the advancement discussed … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary | Tagged | 1 Comment

Underpowered: Samurai (3.5E)

The samurai has been ranked by very smart people as perhaps the least-powerful PC class in D&D 3.5. Apparently it’s on par with the expert, the adept, and other NPC classes. I think it’s common knowledge that non-spellcasting classes are … Continue reading

Posted in Gaming Systems, Underpowered | Tagged | 7 Comments

Players Making Failure Interesting

So we had a TPK on Saturday. The party came across the guardian to a gate we had to open. In the first round, the fighter won initiative, charged, and did 75 points of damage in one hit, dropping the … Continue reading

Posted in DMing | 1 Comment

On The Dungeon Master Experience

Chris Perkin’s penultimate article came down last week, which bothers me. As soon as I find an article on Wizard’s site that’s worth reading, it goes away. It’s like Leverage all over again. I was going to link to his … Continue reading

Posted in Commentary, DMing | 3 Comments

Arbitrary Attack Bonuses in 4E

Somebody asked about the correct values for the arbitrary attack bonus that accompanies racial attack powers, item powers, and so forth. I put this together to see exactly how they stack up: This chart assumes the following: A character gets … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged | 1 Comment

Underpowered: Duergar (4E)

Generally I’m not the kind of person who ranks things by power level. I tend to leave that to the experts. But I do talk with people and I see a lot of gameplay. One of the big benefits of … Continue reading

Posted in Gaming Systems, Underpowered | Tagged | 2 Comments